A claim in negligence may arise when a person or business alleges that another party failed to take reasonable care, resulting in loss or damage. In commercial and property matters, alleged negligence may result in property damage, project delays or financial loss. However, suffering a financial loss does not automatically establish a negligence claim. Whether a duty of care exists and the loss can be recovered depends on the circumstances.
Whether you have suffered a loss because of someone else’s conduct, or your business is responding to a claim made against it, negligence claims turn on the detail: what duty was owed, what went wrong, and whether the loss can be recovered. Rockliffs Lawyers is a Sydney CBD civil disputes and litigation firm that gives clear advice on prospects, evidence and strategy in commercial and property negligence matters. We do not act in personal injury or medical negligence compensation claims.
Negligence Claims We Assist With
Our experience in negligence claims centres on matters arising in business and commercial contexts. We act for clients pursuing claims and for those defending them. Matters we assist with include:
- Losses caused by a building consultant or engineer whose negligence on a project led to extensive delays and costs, often connected to wider building and construction disputes
- Claims against real estate agents for negligently managing a client’s property, resulting in damage to the home
- Negligence claims arising from commercial dealings, which may run alongside related contract and property disputes
- Insurance-related disputes involving professional indemnity and public liability insurance, having acted for both insurers and individuals through our insurance law practice
What Is a Claim in Negligence?
Negligence law in Australia was first developed through the common law, meaning its principles were shaped by decisions of the courts. In NSW, negligence is now also governed by the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW).
Put simply, a claim in negligence arises where one party fails to take reasonable care and another party suffers harm that was a foreseeable result of that failure. Harm can include property damage, personal injury, and economic or financial loss.
Elements of a Negligence Cause of Action
To succeed, the person bringing the claim must establish each of the following four elements. If any one of them cannot be proven, the claim will not succeed.
- Duty of care: The other party owed a duty to take reasonable care towards the person who suffered the loss.
- Breach of duty: That duty was breached because the other party did not take the care required.
- Causation: The breach caused the loss or damage that was suffered.
- Remoteness of damage: The loss was not too remote. In other words, it was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the negligent act.
A negligence cause of action is often brought alongside other claims. For example, where there was a contractual obligation between the parties, a breach of contract claim may be pursued at the same time.
When Is a Duty of Care Owed?
The courts have recognised a duty of care in certain established relationships, including:
- Lawyer and client
- Doctor and patient
- Teacher and student
- Landlord and tenant
- Manufacturer and consumer
This is not an exhaustive list. Whether a duty of care is owed in a particular matter is ultimately decided case by case, on its own merits.
Time Limits for Negligence Claims in NSW
Most legal claims must be started within a set period, known as a limitation period. If proceedings are not commenced in time, the claim may become “statute barred” and the right to pursue it may be lost. In NSW, these periods are set by the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) and by common law principles developed through the courts.
For property damage or economic loss, a negligence claim generally must be commenced within six years from the date the cause of action first accrues. In negligence, this is generally when the loss or damage is first suffered.
Personal injury claims are subject to different time limits and procedures.
A person with a negligence claim may also have related or ancillary claims, and each may carry a different time limit. If you believe you have a claim, seeking legal advice promptly helps protect all of your options.
When Does a Cause of Action Accrue?
As a general rule, a cause of action accrues when it is complete, meaning the first day on which legal proceedings could properly have been commenced. Because damage is an essential part of a negligence claim, the cause of action generally accrues when loss or damage is suffered.
The courts have also found that where the value of a loss cannot be ascertained at the time a transaction is entered into, such as when providing a personal guarantee and indemnity, loss is not suffered before it is reasonably ascertainable. When loss or damage occurs is a question of fact and will differ from case to case.
What If the Limitation Period Has Expired or Is About to Expire?
If you think the limitation period may have already expired, or is close to expiring, seek legal advice immediately. In certain circumstances, such as where a person is under a legal disability, a limitation period may be extended or may stop running. A lawyer can assess whether this applies to your situation and what steps need to be taken without delay.
How Rockliffs Lawyers Can Help with Negligence Claims
Whether you are pursuing a claim of negligence or responding to one, our team can assist with:
- Assessing whether conduct may amount to negligence and whether your loss is recoverable
- Advising on prospects, evidence and strategy
- Identifying limitation periods and any related claims early
- Pursuing or defending claims in the Supreme, District and Local Courts through our commercial litigation practice
Not every dispute needs to end up in court. Where appropriate, we can explore negotiation or alternative dispute resolution (ADR) to resolve a matter before litigation begins.
Speak with Our Negligence Lawyers in Sydney
If you believe your business or property has suffered loss because someone failed to take reasonable care, or your business is facing a claim in negligence, contact Rockliffs Lawyers. Limitation periods can restrict your options, so early advice matters.
Frequently Asked Questions
What do I need to prove in a claim of negligence?
You need to establish four elements: that a duty of care was owed, that the duty was breached, that the breach caused the loss, and that the loss was not too remote. Each element must be proven for the claim to succeed. Whether a duty of care existed is decided on the facts of each matter. Early advice can help you understand how your evidence supports each element.
What types of loss can a negligence claim cover?
Harm in a negligence claim can include property damage, personal injury, and economic or financial loss. The type of loss affects how the claim is assessed and which limitation period applies. Our negligence work focuses on commercial and property matters, such as losses from project delays or damage to a managed property. We do not act in personal injury or medical negligence claims.
How long do I have to make a negligence claim in NSW?
It depends on the type of claim. Claims for property damage or economic loss generally must be commenced within six years from when the cause of action accrues. Personal injury claims are subject to different time limits and procedures. Related claims may also have different time limits, so seek advice as early as possible.
Can a negligence claim be brought together with a breach of contract claim?
Yes. A negligence cause of action is often brought alongside other claims, including breach of contract where there was a contractual obligation between the parties. Each claim may have its own requirements and time limit. Reviewing all potential claims together helps ensure your position is fully considered.
Can Rockliffs Lawyers act for me if a negligence claim is made against my business?
Yes. We act for clients both pursuing and defending negligence claims. We can review the claim, assess whether each element can be established against your business, and advise on evidence and strategy. Where appropriate, we can also explore resolving the matter through negotiation or alternative dispute resolution.
